I think it’s important that we avoid slipping onto a situation where we are all saying what we think, but not answering questions posed by others. Let’s start with these:

Orac. Are you implying that if I had said: "Enormous! but it will never be infinite." That would have been incorrect; but because I gave my reason for saying that, my statement became correct?

Bill. How do you know when (if) you have an infinite number of apples, or bananas?

Finiter. (one not already asked) What is an infinitely small particle, and how does it differ from nothing?

There never was nothing.