Originally Posted By: Bill
Bill S. The problem with Finiters ideas is that he doesn't really share them. He makes a lot of statements, and doesn't explain how they are generated. Without an explanation of his theory that we can follow we don't really have any way to evaluate it. Keep in mind that any physical theory has to be validated by experiment before it becomes any more than a hypothesis. So far Finiter hasn't even told us in detail what his theory is.

Science requires that any hypothesis must be stated in enough detail so that others can evaluate it. Worked out examples are invaluable, so that people can check the work to see if it is correct. With no more than Finiter has given us the only conclusion I can reach is that he is a crackpot who is trying to push an impossible theory. If he does have a real theory he will have to come up with something more than he has given us so far.Bill Gill

I agree with all you have stated, except the conclusion that you have arrived at. Here I have put forth an alternate view regarding the physical world, just to discuss it. As a part of it, I have put forth some of my differing views, which I consider to be logical (only logical, may not be correct).