Originally Posted By: Bill S.
Originally Posted By: toto
agree


Perhaps, if you say why you agree, it might help with the general understanding. I don't seem to be getting my point across. smile


I agree too :P

It's been shown to have no value because different bullet-apple situations have totally different behaviours. Some consistent with Earth remaining intact and some not.

That shows the analogy is meaningless and people shouldn't bother using it. It's an appeal to common sense which is unscientific and totally useless for sorting out a radical claim.