Originally Posted By: Bill S.
Did that surprise you? Are solutions that produce infinities not usually problematic?


Strange statement there are many solutions that produce infinities which aren't in any way problematic. The most obvious even layman are familiar with is the formula for a straight line produces an infinity which is never remotely an issue in normal use.


Originally Posted By: Bill S.
Is this the sort of thing that Jim Baggott means by “fairytale physics”?


Bit like your answer above I am not sure remotely what you have an issue with.


Originally Posted By: Bill S.
Perfect! For mathematical infinities.


And many real world infinities as well I am not sure why you feel you can just exclude them and this has been my issue all along you keep trying to avoid the issue of validity by just declaring it so, I am at least trying to put a formal definition under validity which is the interesting part of this rubbish.

I believe in "Evil, Bad, Ungodly fantasy science and maths", so I am undoubtedly wrong to you.