Originally posted by Johnny Boy:
Originally posted by Count Iblis II:
Your arguments have already been refuted here. But you simply refuse to accept that and then you introduce new nonsensical arguments like that radiation should be emitted by the currents.
I think you are the one here who doesn't understand electromagnetism. If you did then you would know what is wrong with your argument.
Have you ever derived the formulas for radiation emitted by accelerated charges? Oviously not! If you just pick up a book like e.g. the book by Jackson then you will see that a circular current does not emit any radiation. If you have a steady current then the fields are constant and that cannot gove rise to radiation. The fact that charges are accelerated is not relevant.
If you have a single charge that is accelerated then you do have radiation. But the reason for that radiation is the way the fields from that accelerated charge behave.
Of course, I cannot be very precise here so don't try to argue with me on these points based on imprecise language.
