Lets get Boolean:

If 2 then the deity, by definition, is not a deity. All deities MUST be capable of the supernatural and all deities defined by human thologies DO work outisde of natural law.

If 3 then all those that have "spoken" with a deity are liars: Inlcuding essentially everyone in all of the theological texts.

If 4 then all of the texts about deities are lying about what the deity has done.

If 1 then there is no point even thinking about said deity as, by definition, we can not comprehend it. In this category, alas, is the invisible purple rhinoceros.

DA Morgan