Originally posted by DA Morgan:
You've the patience of a saint JAG.
After the way he treated you I wouldn't respond to him if he was up to his neck in quicksand.
People that rail against "the establishment" may or may not have a point. But they are always setting themselves up for failure.
Actually, I was not pleased with statements in the previous thread. I asked some questions, and JB made responses. I didn't agree with them, but didn't have time to make a post. He implied that my silence somehow implied that he had convinced me. I want to be very clear this time.
I must say that I find his recent arguments odd.
His theory has nothing to say on the isotope effect at all. He has suggested some handwaving arguments in this forum.
BCS explains the isotope effect well in standard materials but not so well in High-Tc.
Therefore, we are to conclude that BCS is wrong and he is correct.
