I don't know that I need qualifications to question your assessements. I would need qualification, perhaps, to evaluate your assessment - but I don't think I need qualifications to ask.

Your criterion that a good scientist must believe in god seems utterly orthogonal to the facts. You're telling me that Dirac, Crick, Marie Curie, and Feynman were not good scientists? One might just as defensibly say that no good scientist dislikes peanut butter.