so you are in agreement that temperatures are not causing the
melting then , that's fine with me.

its the soot and the land use etc ... that's causing the melting
... ( human causes other than CO2 ).

I can agree with that also.

all this time I was under the impression that you believed
that rising temperatures due to the increase in CO2 levels
in the atmosphere was causing the melting of ice.

I can agree that more ice is melting , I just cant agree that
a rise in temperatures is causing the melting.

because there isn't any rise in temperatures.

so do we now start a cap n trade of soot and land use program?

LOL





3/4 inch of dust build up on the moon in 4.527 billion years,LOL and QM is fantasy science.