Originally Posted By: Orac
You really should try reading more before showing how ignorant you are

I'd like to offer you some unsolicited advice. Please take it in the spirit it is intended discard if you don't think it fits your style; trying to argue with members like newton is a waste of time. You know him well enough to know that not only is he not able to follow the reasoning behind physics but that he doesn't seem to be able to construct any kind of logical argument but can merel string together unrelated nonsense. I recommend ignoring him and saving yourself the argrevation. I've dealt with the likes of him for some 15 years now and believe beyond all doubt that you just can't get through to some people and newton is just that sort of person.

Note: You wrote

That page was written by Steve Carlip, an expert on general relativity. He can't be referred to a layman by any sense of the word.