Originally Posted By: preearth
Originally Posted By: ImagingGeek
you've ignored what has happened every single time two heavenly bodies have collided.

Oh right,... why don't you list the recorded instances of two heavenly bodies colliding.

Lets see:
1) formation of every planet in our solar system,
2) formation of the moon from the earth
3) every crater on every moon in our solar system
4) every crater on every planet in our solar system

Strangely, none of those led to nice mergers like you propose, but rather one body blasting the hell out of the other.

You truly are weird.

Take just the one example quoted above.

The reason I wanted recorded instances (i.e., observed events with the results of the collision recorded) of two heavenly bodies colliding is so that we would have a scientific basis on which to go forward.

However, you supply a list of unrecorded, i.e., unobserved events and then attach your OPINION to them.

Your OPINION that they would be "one body blasting the hell out of the other."

Since, you weren't at such an event (and neither was anyone else) you can't say what a collision between two planets half the volume of Earth would be like.

Oh,... I am sorry, you can say what a collision between two planets half the volume of Earth would be like, as you have.

But you have no evidence for your claim.

So, you make clear that you are a propagandist not a scientist.


Earth formed from a collision
www.preearth.net

Plate-tectonics is wrong
www.preearth.net/plate.html