Say what? Ambiguity makes language more efficient

To avoid conversational confusion and optimize language, linguists have traditionally argued that every word should have just one meaning, but a new study from MIT turns that notion on its head, showing instead that ambiguity in words actually makes language more efficient. The new study, published in the journalCognition, proposes that ambiguity increases efficiency by allowing for the reuse of short, efficient sounds that listeners can easily disambiguate with the help of context.

“Various people have said that ambiguity is a problem for communication,” says MIT’s Ted Gibson, senior author of the paper. “But once we understand that context disambiguates, then ambiguity is not a problem – it’s something you can take advantage of, because you can reuse easy [words] in different contexts over and over again.”

As an example, Gibson cites the word “mean.” It can, er, mean: indicate or signify, refer to an intention or purpose (“I meant to go to the store”), something offensive, or the mathematical average of a set of numbers. Adding an “s” introduces even more potential definitions: a method (“a means to an end”), or financial resources (“to live within one’s means”).

But Gibson says that virtually no speaker of English gets confused when she hears the word “mean” because the different senses of the word occur in such different contexts as to allow listeners to infer its meaning easily. Building on observation and previous studies, the researchers posited that words with fewer syllables, high frequency and the simplest pronunciations should have the most meanings.

To test this notion, Gibson and his co-researchers carried out an analysis of word frequencies and patterns in English, Dutch and German. By comparing certain properties of words to their numbers of meanings, the researchers confirmed their suspicion that shorter, more frequent words, as well as those that conform to the language’s typical sound patterns, are most likely to be ambiguous. These trends were statistically significant in all three languages.

Gibson said that these findings need to be considered in light of the competing desires of the speaker and the listener. The speaker is interested in conveying as much as possible with the fewest possible words, while the listener is aiming to get a complete and specific understanding of what the speaker is trying to say. “It is cognitively cheaper to have the listener infer certain things from the context than to have the speaker spend time on longer and more complicated utterances. The result is a system that skews toward ambiguity, reusing the ‘easiest’ words. Once context is considered, it’s clear that “ambiguity is actually something you would want in the communication system,” explained co-researcher Steven Piantadosi.

Gibson believes the findings underscore the special challenges faced by computer scientists working in the field of natural language processing. “Basically, if you have any human language in your input or output, you are stuck with needing context to disambiguate,” he concluded.

Related:
Discuss this article in our forum
Language transforming medicine… for the worse
Couples’ language use predicts relationship success
“Language” Gene Pooh-Poohed
The Rain In Spain Falls Only In The Human Brain

Source: Massachusetts Institute of Technology

, ,

Comments are closed.

Soul Eater Japanese language Vol.1-25 Set  Manga GanGan comics Atsushi Ohkubo picture

Soul Eater Japanese language Vol.1-25 Set Manga GanGan comics Atsushi Ohkubo

$74.00



Army Military Issue Iraqi Language Survival Guide April 2003 picture

Army Military Issue Iraqi Language Survival Guide April 2003

$15.00



Taiyo Matsumoto Manga Lot - Sunny, Number 5, Black &White (Japanese Language) picture

Taiyo Matsumoto Manga Lot - Sunny, Number 5, Black &White (Japanese Language)

$40.00



c1910 Language Of Flowers FORGET-ME-NOTS AND AFFECTION FLOWERS AC5097 picture

c1910 Language Of Flowers FORGET-ME-NOTS AND AFFECTION FLOWERS AC5097

$2.02



NANA Japanese language Vol.1-21 set Manga Comics Ai Yazawa Japanese ver picture

NANA Japanese language Vol.1-21 set Manga Comics Ai Yazawa Japanese ver

$69.79



Vintage book c1976... premier leather - novel JAWS, Benchley... French language picture

Vintage book c1976... premier leather - novel JAWS, Benchley... French language

$59.83



KING GEORGE III (1760) HANDWRITTEN SPEECH EXCERPT - RARE FINE PRESS - FACSIMILE picture

KING GEORGE III (1760) HANDWRITTEN SPEECH EXCERPT - RARE FINE PRESS - FACSIMILE

$12.00



ORIGINAL 1893 WILLIAM JENNINGS BRYAN  HOUSE SPEECH SHERMAN SILVER ACT - VG COND. picture

ORIGINAL 1893 WILLIAM JENNINGS BRYAN HOUSE SPEECH SHERMAN SILVER ACT - VG COND.

$31.50



2021 Starbucks American Sign Language ASL 24oz Iridescent Tumbler Cold Cup NEW picture

2021 Starbucks American Sign Language ASL 24oz Iridescent Tumbler Cold Cup NEW

$44.95



Tokyo Ghoul Japanese Language Vol.1-14 set Complete Manga Comics  Shonen Jump  picture

Tokyo Ghoul Japanese Language Vol.1-14 set Complete Manga Comics Shonen Jump

$64.98



Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes