29 April 2011
Scans reveal brain's in-built caste system
by Kate Melville
Reporting their findings in Current Biology, National Institute of Mental Health researchers say that people of higher subjective socioeconomic status show greater brain activity in response to other high-ranked individuals, while those with lower status have a greater response to other low-status individuals.
The functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scans show the differences registering in a key component of the brain's value system, a region known as the ventral striatum.
Researcher Caroline Zink said the findings in humans are largely consistent with past observations in monkeys. It had previously been shown that monkeys direct their attention to others of higher or lower status depending on their own position in the troop.
"The way we interact with and behave around other people is often determined by their social status relative to our own, and therefore information regarding social status is very valuable to us," said Zink. "Interestingly, the value we assign to information about someone's particular status seems to depend on our own status."
The scans were taken while participants of varying social status were shown information about someone of relatively higher status and information about someone of relatively lower status. They revealed that the brain's response to status cues varied depending on an individual's own subjective status.
"The value that we place on particular status-related information - evident by the extent our brain's value centers are activated - is not the same for everyone and is influenced, at least in part, by our own subjective socioeconomic status," Zink said.
She added that socioeconomic status isn't based solely on money but can also include factors such as accomplishments and habits. And of course, our socioeconomic status isn't fixed; it shifts over time, for better or for worse. Exactly how the brain will respond to such changes is an intriguing question for future study.
"As humans, we have the capacity to assess our surroundings and context to determine appropriate feelings and behavior," Zink said. "We, and our brain's activity, are not static and can adjust depending on the circumstances. As one's status changes, I would expect that the value we place on status-related information from others and corresponding brain activity in the ventral striatum would also change."
Source: Current Biology