As I said I have no intention of ever discussing your idea again but since you bought up Mr LUCJAN LAGIEWKA it is worth telling you what will happen to his patent in USA, UK and Australia which all have similar patent laws. The status in other countries will depend on each countries patent laws.
LUCJAN LAGIEWKA will unfortunately be denied a patent on his invention on those 3 countries even though he without doubt attempted to patent the idea first.
The reason is simple the patent laws work under a very simple system here is the guidelines
http://www.uspto.gov/inventors/patents.jspHere are the three big points:
What cannot be patented:
=> Abstract ideas
Invention must also be:
=>Adequately described or enabled (for one of ordinary skill in the art to make and use the invention)
=>Claimed by the inventor in clear and definite termsAs you know the idea was later patented and accepted by Oxford University professor Malcolm Smith and ended up on F1 cars as a J-Damper.
Unfortunately LUCJAN LAGIEWKA claims the device breaks Newtons laws of physics and hence he has massive problems with patent laws as professor Malcolm Smith's patent clearly shows the device conforms to all the normal laws of physics.
The judgement of the patent office in those three countries will therefore rule against LUCJAN LAGIEWKA on the three grounds
1. His design is an abstract idea (the physics is wrong)
2. He does not adequately described the invention (the physics is wrong)
3. He has not claimed the invention in clear and definite terms (the physics is wrong)
Having got all the theory wrong his only hope would therefore have been to demonstrate a working version of the device to the patent office prior to Prof Smiths patent which he didn't do. There is argument that may be the fault of the polish patent office but that will not change the outcome in other countries and will be a legal matter between him and the polish patent office.
The patent will be almost certainly be upheld in those 3 countries to belong to professor Malcolm Smith who correctly describes the correct physics and demonstrated it. That is why no car manufacturers or companies are interested in discussing it with LUCJAN LAGIEWKA because he won't be able to even sell the product in those countries as Prof Smith's patent will exist there. At this stage I think the best LUCJAN LAGIEWKA can hope for is the patent will be granted in Poland and parts of Europe but I even doubt that.
I do feel sorry for LUCJAN LAGIEWKA but the patent law is very specific on these matters. It is not like Professor Smith stole the idea you have two people arrive at the same invention a few years apart it appears they knew nothing of each others work and certainly LUCJAN LAGIEWKA never published his idea anywhere.
There is a huge lesson in that for you Maciej MaroszI can guess your reaction it is all a huge conspiracy
Sorry in patent law theory and mathematics is everything in the absence of a fully working invention
