Science a GoGo's Home Page
Posted By: Anonymous gravity acts on light? - 08/21/05 07:36 AM
Does GRAVITY act upon light?
Its been buggin me man.If it acts you could see things that happen in South Pole right![only when nothing is between u & the Pole].If it doesn't act then if I send a powerful beam of light wouldn't it reach moon and so on in space.
Guys,give me an answer OK.

Best regards.
Posted By: DA Morgan Re: gravity acts on light? - 08/21/05 07:21 PM
Absolutely. Something predicted by Einstein and proven in the early part of the previous century.

Gravity acts on nothing.

Gravity warps space and time.

As gravity acts through space ... and over time ... it is affected.

Might I suggest to you a couple of good reads ... Briane Greene's "The Elegant Universe" and "The Fabric of the Cosmos."
Posted By: Uncle Al Re: gravity acts on light? - 08/21/05 11:58 PM
http://arXiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9909014
Amer. J. Phys. 71 770 (2003)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 121101 (2004)
falling light
Posted By: finchbeak Re: gravity acts on light? - 08/22/05 12:27 AM
Quote:
Originally posted by DA Morgan:
Might I suggest to you a couple of good reads ... Briane Greene's "The Elegant Universe" and "The Fabric of the Cosmos."
Terrific books. I second the suggestion.
Posted By: jjw Re: gravity acts on light? - 09/13/05 09:56 PM
Brianwave asks ?Does gravity effect light?

You will get advice to read Einstein?s work. I am not knowledgeable in Einstein?s work but I have a little understanding of how he explained light was affected by gravity, or possibly not, within this solar system. Newton?s theories are very mechanical wanting to tell us the weight, mass, of all the things and then calculate the probable attraction that an objects mass might have on another object with a mass of its own. There was an exception for light because the consensus was that light has no mass of its own.

It was noted that stars behind the sun could be visible here on earth at times and Einstein theorized that for the light to be seen space must be bent around massive objects and the light was curving around the sun because the space around the sun is ?warped?. You may have seen an example of this when educators place a billiard ball on a net stretched over a ring and the ball makes a depression when it rolls around on the net. This is to be an example of how massive objects warp space. The curve in space depicts the path light would travel to us from behind the sun.

I would like to see a model of the entire solar system with all the warping of hundreds of objects interplay. It would be educational. When objects fall to earth it is difficult to see a curve in real time because they seem to fall straight down depending on their original trajectory upon entering the atmosphere.

All most all calculations regarding planet and satellites are made using Newton?s theories and are still in use every day. He did not have an explanation for the path of the light, and I am not sure the issue ever came up back then, and Einstein?s theory was accepted as valid. I recognize my ignorance in this regard and I am unable to tell you why light can not be bent by gravity because it has no mass but empty space with no mass can be bent and or warped by gravity. Some other member will explain it for you.

Jim Wood
Posted By: jjw Re: gravity acts on light? - 09/16/05 10:00 PM
Hi Brainwave:

Possibly someone sent you an answer privately?
It is a very thoughtfull question but don't waste your time by looking for the back of your pants or the crew of the Mayflower landing on the Americas. Think of light as a picture you may click with a camera. That picture details are gone never to be visioned again. Theory, if that is the name for it, may argue that if that very same light that assisted you in the creation of that picture continued to travel in space and you were looking at earth with your super power scope from Mars at the right time you might see the same light that entered the camera on earth and possibly see the picture as the camera saw it. Wow. That is light travel.

You are not going to see things comming around again. Even if the universe was limited and spherical any light that made the trip would have faded away long before you looked for it. Light and time are here then gone. Time is a creation of man as a measure and does not equate to nature in my mind. Days are relative to the location of the object, sunrise and sunset are as well- and relate to our earth focus.

Sorry, I did not mean to get carried away. I recently read some argument for time travel and I shouted here. Have a great day.
© Science a GoGo's Discussion Forums