JAG: "Berkeley tried to impose a quota on Asians because they were over-represented. However, they were not able to do so. So, claiming that
Responded to
TFF: "The problem isn't that all jews and asians are excluded, but that some are excluded in preference to people who are far less qualified."
Quotas are not the only way that preferential treatment can be implemented (I gave an example of another mechanism) - simply have to widely disparate standards for different sets of applicants.
JAG: "it is impossible for Uncle Al to complain about that special program (NSF grants for women and minorities) given his own history."
I.e. statements like:
Al: "Official compassion has assassinated the future by destroying its sources at incredible taxpayer expense."
JAG: ring hollow from a person who has wasted taxpayer funds.
TFF: Do you have data that Al wasted taxpayer funds? That he did not finish his degree doesn't mean he wasted his NSF grant.
