Quote:
Originally posted by DA Morgan:
Dr. R. wrote:
"It seems that you have answered your own question"

What additional comment are you looking for? That the wallpaper is the wrong color? That the lawn needs edging?
The additional comment I am looking for is whether scientists agree that any theory based on equating a circular field to a conservative field must be wrong. This would imply that the macroscopic mechanism that forms the basis to explain superconduction (both by Landau and Ginsberg, as well as Bardeen, Cooper, Schrieffer) must be wrong. Do you agree?