I think we are in agreement but I'll state my case yet again using different terms.

I put an Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, the Pope, a Sunni Imam, and an animist in a room. Stick a thermometer into a pot of water and say: "Tell me at what temperature the water freezes." They will all agree.

Now I say to the same group: "Show me proof that your god is the one true god and everyone else in the room is wrong." They will never agree.

One is science.
The other is faith.
The result is purely Boolean.

DA Morgan